Robinson Redux

In Milan, down a side street

I first became acquainted with architect and philosopher Sarah Robinson in 2012 when I came across her book Nesting at one of my favorite bookstores in San Francisco. After falling under the spell of Juhani Pallasmaa‘s extraordinary book, The Eyes of the Skin, I sensed immediately that Robinson was approaching architecture and aesthetics with a complementary point of view.

Turns out Sarah and Juhani are close friends. They have collaborated on a number of publications and seminars, and both of them are continuing to deepen their explorations into a more holistic approach to architecture and the built environment. Their wisdom and research continues to speak to many of my concerns about painting and the experience of the visual in that domain.

Since that first introduction to Nesting four years ago, Sarah and I have become friends and cotravelers. Now that she lives in Italy, I spend time with her every time I visit my daughter and her family in Florence. We spent a magical day in Milan last week exploring architecture as well as the back alleys and hidden chambers of Milan’s world famous designers. And lunch was a tireless sharing of favorite books and authors.

Bosco Verticale, in Milan

I am posting my original review of her book from 2012 here because her work deserves ongoing and steady attention. In addition to Nesting, Sarah has written and edited a number of other essays and publications including Architecture and Empathy (essays by Juhani Pallasmaa, Harry Francis Mallgrave, Vittorio Gallese and Sarah Robinson), and Mind in Architecture (edited by Juhani Pallasmaa and Sarah Robinson.)

Note: More Slow Muse posts about Sarah and Juhani Pallasma are listed at the bottom of the review.

From November 2012…

William Stout Books, San Francisco

San Francisco’s William Stout Architectural Books is located on the periphery of North Beach, just a few blocks from the better known City Lights. Both bookshops are labyrinthine and lushly overstuffed. But Stout and me, we have a mystical connection. I never leave that narrow two storied jewel box without some treasure under my arm. And the latest find is my all time best: Nesting: Body, Dwelling, Mind, by Sarah Robinson.

This small book is an exquisite set of essays that goes well beyond the domain of architecture. Her world view blends philosophy, poetry, biology and wisdom to offer a concise and clearly written meditation on how to think about who we are as humans in this grand adventure. My library has a shelf full of books that explore these complex themes of art making and human consciousness (Gaston Bachelard, Merleau-Ponty, Martin Heidegger, Edward Hall, E. V. Walter among many others), and Robinson references many of them in her notes. But none of those writers offer up what she has achieved: A human sized, perfectly tuned invitation into the world of these ideas. Malcolm Gladwell refers to “amplitude” as the gastronome’s measure of how flavors come together in such exquisite compliance that the recipe cannot be improved. Robinson’s book is high amplitude in written form.

And as an object itself, the book is also a feast. Small in format, the book includes images that sit well positioned amid the beautifully laid out printed words. (Like other William Stout Publishers books, Nesting has been designed with great attention to detail.)

The introduction was written by Juhani Pallasmaa, an architect and theorist I have written about many times on Slow Muse (and the author of one of my favorite books, Eyes of the Skin.) Robinson’s chapter headings say something about the range of her purveiw: Of Havens, The Mind of the Skin, Practically Unconscious, Dark Matters, Love is Paying Attention, Belonging, To Dwell in Possibility. Each of these chapters could fill several posts, full of provocative insights and the fresh comingling of ideas.

And how timely. To read this book about the nature of place and how we are with our world is particularly apropos at a time when all of us are freshly aware of the devastation of homes and communities caught in Sandy’s force field.

That’s a worthy place to start. Here are a few passages that speak to those complex circumstances:

***
Our environment mirrors what we have come to believe about our relations and ourselves: that all are re-place-able, the palpable echo of Cartesian solopcism. The natural environment, local culture, and social patterns, once dominant factors shaping the character of a place, are now only marginal determinants…Dislocated from the tissue of community, people are routinely forced to start tabula rasa, a norm all the more insidious because it is equated with freedom.

***
Places [in the past] were not commodities, they were dense contexts of communally-lived history as well as a source of one’s personal identity.

***
Our feelings about a particular place may be personal, but the feelings grow out of collective experiences that do not occur elsewhere. They are specific to and belong to the place. People and place participate in one another’s sustenance, and places perish along with the disappearance of people who cherish them. We dwell in places in a paradgim of mutual influences.

***
Perhaps we can understand place as a basin of attraction, a matrix that evokes and sustains our imagination. E. V. Walter writes:

“Towns may die for all sorts of reasons, but expressive vitality depends on how a place engages the imagination. A place is dead if the physique dos not support the work of the imagination, if the mind cannot engage with the experience located there, or if the local energy fails to evoke ideas, images or feelings…’Where do I belong?’ is a question addressed to the imagination. To inhabit a place physically but to remain unaware of what it means, or how it feels, is a deprivation more profund that deafness at a concert or blindess at an art gallery. Humans in this condition belong nowhere.”

More, much more, to come.

Sarah Robinson

More information about Sarah Robinson’s architectural practice here.

________
Previous posts on Slow Muse:

Sarah Robinson:

Born Things

Signature of the Landscape

Bento Reimagined

Juhani Pallasma:

Enchantment Becoming Thing

The Perspectival Eye

Sensing the flow of Water Against the Skin

Sensory Intimacy, in Art and in Architecture

Fully Engaged

Architecture and Beauty

Human Rootedness

The Eye in the Hand

Mind and Eye

Inside and Outside, at the Same Time

Focused Vs Peripheral Vision

Whole Body Seeing

The Small Ones